Rationality slides

Here is a presentation (in spanish) on rationality for skepticamp I’ve worked on recently. It needs some polish but the content is essentially complete. A summary of the main points

  • Optimization and the second law of thermodynamics are opposing forces
  • Intelligence is a type of optimization that evolved in certain species to counteract the 2nd law through behavior. Intelligence functions through observation, learning and prediction
  • Prediction requires a correct representation of the environment, this defines epistemic rationality as a component of intelligence
  • Classical logic fails to model rationality as it cannot deal with uncertainty
  • Probability theory is an extension of logic to domains with uncertainty
  • Probability theory and Bayes define a standard of ideal rationality. Other methods are suboptimal approximations
  • Probability theory as formalization of rationality:
    • Provides a quantitative model of the scientific method as a special case of Bayes theorem
    • Provides operational, quantitative definitions of belief and evidence
    • Naturally relates predictive power and falsifiability through the sum rule of probability
    • Explains pathological beliefs of the vacuous kind; astrology, card reading, divination, etc
    • Explains pathological beliefs of the floating kind; “There is a dragon in my garage”
    • Exposes fraudulent retrodiction; astrology, cold reading, ad-hoc hypothesis, bad science, bad economics, etc
    • Dissolves false disagreements described by matching predictions but different verbal formulations
    • Naturally embeds empiricism, positivism and falsificationism
  • Pathological beliefs can be analyzed empirically by re-casting them as physical phenomena in brains, the province of cognitive science.
  • A naturalistic perspective automatically explains human deviations from rationality; evolution will always favor adaptations that increase fitness even if they penalize rationality
  • Today, politics is an example of rationality catastrophe; in the ancestral environment, irrationality that favored survival in a social context (tribes) was a successful adaptation. (Wright, Yudkowsky)

    Recommended reading

    Probability Theory: The Logic of Science
    Bayesian Theory (Wiley Series in Probability and Statistics)
    Hume’s Problem: Induction and the Justification of Belief

    Various papers

    Bayesian probability – Bruyninckx(2002)
    Philosophy and the practice of Bayesian statistics – Gelman(2011)
    Varieties of Bayesianism – Weisberg
    No Free Lunch versus Occam’s Razor in Supervised Learning – Lattimore, Hutter(2011)
    A Material Theory of Induction – Norton(2002)
    Bayesian epistemology – Hartmann, Sprenger(2010)
    The Illusion of Ambiguity: from Bistable Perception to Anthropomorphism – Ghedini(2011)
    Bayesian Rationality and Decision Making: A Critical Review – Albert(2003)
    Why Bayesian Rationality Is Empty, Perfect Rationality Doesn’t Exist, Ecological Rationality Is Too Simple, and Critical Rationality Does the Job* – Albert(2009)
    A Better Bayesian Convergence Theorem – Hawthorne

    Bayesian epistemology (stanford)
    lesswrong.com (excellent blog on rationality)

    4 thoughts on “Rationality slides

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *